A man narrowly escaped jail after deceiving dog lovers into purchasing puppies of uncertain origins from his farm, many of which suffered from health issues. Richard Butler, operating from Springfield Farm in Rugeley, Staffordshire, sourced popular dog breeds from various locations across England and Wales.
Butler falsely advertised the dogs online, claiming they were first litters or the offspring of family pets, despite having no knowledge of their true pedigree. The 57-year-old also forged documents, including vaccination records, to further deceive buyers.
Many of the puppies he sold had congenital defects or serious infections, with some ultimately having to be euthanized. According to Staffordshire Trading Standards, which prosecuted Butler, he unlawfully sold approximately 500 puppies for around £500 each between October 2015 and May 2018.
A spokesperson revealed that Butler had been previously denied a license to sell dogs due to the poor conditions on his farm.
Richard Butler pleaded guilty to three charges of making false representations and one count of making or supplying documents for fraudulent use. During a hearing at Stafford Crown Court, he was sentenced to 21 months in prison, suspended for two years, along with 200 hours of unpaid community work.
Judge Kristina Montgomery, who presided over the case, condemned Butler as “greedy, selfish, and unsympathetic,” noting the severe emotional harm and distress he caused to those who purchased puppies from him.
A separate court hearing will determine any financial penalties Butler may face.
Councillor Victoria Wilson, cabinet member for Trading Standards at Staffordshire County Council, encouraged anyone with concerns about a puppy purchase to contact the authorities. She highlighted how the high demand for popular dog breeds often makes it a “very lucrative business.” Wilson emphasized that Staffordshire’s animal health team is committed to upholding good animal welfare standards and taking swift action against fraudulent practices.